offensive holy war was ordained by the Bab, and the Baha'i representation of the Bab and His message is inaccurate.

In various places MacEoin has argued that an offensive, and not merely a defensive, holy war was ordained by the Báb, and that the Bahá’í representation of the Báb and His message is inaccurate. MacEoin’s views on this issue are summarized in his 1982 article,“The Babi Concept of Holy War.”

(Gate of the Heart by Nader Saiedi)

But Nader Saiedi being a Baha'i scholar loyal to the Haifa based UHJ defends the Baha'i narrative and tries to refute MacEoin.